With Clarity Review (2024) – Scam or Legit?

With Clarity

USD 350
4.6

Price

4.5/5

Service

5.0/5

Selection

4.5/5

Features

4.5/5

People & Planet

4.5/5

Pros

  • Excellent value for money
  • Decent lab-grown selection
  • Free home replica previews
  • Dedicated to engagement rings (fully customized)

Cons

  • Limited selection (other than engagement rings)
  • Diamond inspection features nowhere near Clean Origin and James Allen

We test all recommended products and services independently and exhaustively. If you buy through our links, we might receive compensation. Our recommendations are not influenced by monetary considerations. Learn more.

SALES ALERT! Free diamond gift with qualifying purchases at With Clarity!

Summary of Our With Clarity Review

With Clarity (withclarity.com) is a fast-growing online jeweler focused on engagement rings. They offer a large selection of excellent value lab-grown diamonds and a unique try-a-replica-before-you-buy approach. Keep reading our With Clarity review to learn everything you need to know before buying.

Our Bottom-Line Recommendation

We highly recommend With Clarity. And as you’ll learn throughout our review, there are good reasons for that. The lab diamond selection and value for money are great. Coupled with an excellent buying experience, great customer support, and return policies, our review of With Clarity awards them one of our highest ratings.

That’s why With Clarity is one of our recommended jewelers for lab diamond engagement rings and is on our list of the top six best places to buy a lab-grown diamond.

Read more about why we love the With Clarity Home Preview in our review of their free engagement ring replicas. And remember, with a lab-grown diamond engagement ring, you not only save the environment, but you also save 60-80% compared to mined diamonds!

With Clarity Diamonds

Share Your Experiences with With Clarity

Who is With Clarity?

With Clarity started out focusing specifically on engagement rings. The company was born out of a personal need (as many great companies are). The founders wanted to try engagement rings from the comfort of their homes and avoid hustling jewelers. Importantly, they heeded the best diamond and ring that was guaranteed ethically sourced.

But they found that was a tall order, so they solved the challenge themselves. They did this by uniquely offering to create a high-quality replica model of your engagement ring for you to try at home—before the actual ring is made. This is brilliant for both With Clarity (who saves on returned rings) and the consumer (you), who receives some of those savings and has the luxury of shopping from the couch.

Today, With Clarity is one of the fastest-growing and leading online diamond jewelers and one of the best places to buy lab-grown diamond jewelry and engagement rings. They even gained notoriety when they gifted Keltie Knight a replacement diamond ring.

As we’ll learn in the following parts of our With Clarity review, they boast a large selection of high-quality diamonds at some of the lowest lab diamond prices.

With Clarity Quick Facts

Is With Clarity Legit?

With Clarity is a fast-growing online jeweler that offers excellent diamonds and stunning diamond jewelry at fantastic prices. Their selection of diamond jewelry is vast, and their customer service is knowledgeable and helpful. With Clarity is a legit and trustworthy diamond jeweler who we highly recommend. Learn more in our With Clarity review.

Does With Clarity have a showroom?

With Clarity has a showroom in New York City. You can schedule an appointment virtually or at their physical showroom in the Diamond District. The showroom is at 38W 48th Street, New York, NY 10036, but you must book an appointment at their website in advance.

With Clarity’s Home Preview

With Clarity offers to try on a 3D-printed model (replica) of your engagement ring at home – before you buy! This is, to our knowledge, a unique offering and a genius way to avoid going to a jeweler and having to receive and return a costly diamond (with insurance and all). In addition, With Clarity saves on costs since they don’t have to create the actual ring and pass some of the savings on to you in lower prices (more on that later).

The quality of the free Home Preview is one of the reasons we review With Clarity very favorably.
The Home Preview we ordered for our test

Read our in-depth review of the With Clarity Home Preview.

Ethical Diamond Sourcing

You might already know or have read in our the pros and cons of lab-grown diamonds that “ethically mined diamonds” are somewhat of an enigma. Ethical diamond sourcing should be encouraged and even ensured. But, guaranteeing that mined diamonds are ethically sourced has proved almost impossible. It’s a marvelous initiative that we fully support and applaud. But in practice, it is virtually impossible to guarantee that a mined diamond is ethically sourced.

Lab-created diamonds are the only ones guaranteed to be 100% ethically sourced. That’s why lab-grown diamonds are the only sustainable diamond choice. In addition, lab-grown diamonds are cheaper to produce and carry additional benefits, making mined diamonds a poor choice.

So, while we award With Clarity credit for focusing on this, we are much more excited about their focus on lab-created diamonds and their prominence to these sustainably sourced stones. In addition, they have a page dedicated to teaching you about the merits of manufactured diamonds, and they do a reasonably decent job at it.

So, thankfully, With Clarity sells both (purportedly) ethically sourced mined diamonds and lab-grown diamonds. In our review of With Clarity, we applaud them for focusing on this important topic and, at least partly, solving it by making lab-created diamonds a crucial part of their offering.

The Diamond Selection

In this part of our review of With Clarity, we’ll examine their selection of lab-grown diamonds and diamond jewelry.

Today, With Clarity offers a large selection of lab-grown diamonds and does not only sell engagement rings but all types of diamond jewelry. This includes unique and gorgeous jewelry designs and the option to create your own diamond jewelry by pairing diamonds and settings (which we highly recommend that you do).

First, we’ll consider With Clarity’s selection of loose lab-grown diamonds and then its inventory of preset lab diamond jewelry.

Selection of Loose Diamonds

About 40% of their diamond selection is lab-grown, and they have a vast number of stones to choose from. At the time of the review, they have 80,052 lab-grown diamonds on offer (and 115,491 mined diamonds). (Do note that most jewelers do not own all those diamonds, but they have access to them through their network of trusted wholesalers).

In our With Clarity review, we look at how to search for and find the perfect diamond.

But how many of these diamonds are of good quality? We usually use a reference diamond to compare with other lab diamond jewelers. This is a specific range of lab diamond 4C grades, often presenting the best value.

Our reference diamond has the following 4C grades:

When we wrote this review of With Clarity, they had 18 lab diamonds within the above ranges. That is a very decent selection, and you should be able to find at least a good handful among these that satisfy your needs and are fantastic value (we found several ourselves).

We found a good selection of lab diamonds with our reference 4C grades.

Zooming out and including larger diamonds with higher grades, we found almost 75,000 lab diamonds.

Diamond Grading and Certificates

One thing to note about the selection at With Clarity is that they have a large number of GIA-graded lab diamonds. Of the reputable diamond grading institutes, IGI grades most lab diamonds, and most often, you’ll find IGI-graded lab diamonds.

While IGI is a trustworthy diamond lab, GIA is perhaps better known, partly due to GIA inventing the diamond 4C scale, which is most commonly used today. We recommend both IGI and GIA-graded lab diamonds, but some shoppers may have a preference.

GIA charges a bit more for their grading reports, and diamonds graded by them are less common. Therefore, it’s impressive that With Clarity has almost 3,000 GIA-graded high-quality diamonds to choose from (another diamond jeweler with a good selection of GIA-graded lab diamonds is Friendly Diamonds).

We also found a good selection of GIA-graded lab diamonds, which is rare.

With Clarity gives direct access to all lab diamond certificates, which allows you to scrutinize the diamonds you are considering. Of course, all diamond jewelers should do the same, but only a few do (including all our recommended jewelers). In the examples of certificates from IGI and GIA below, you can learn more about the particular diamond and any flaws. Learn more about lab diamond grading and certificates.

A diamond certificate from IGI at With Clarity
A diamond certificate from IGI
A diamond certificate from GIA at With Clarity
A diamond certificate from GIA

Fancy Diamond Colors and Fancy Diamond Shapes

With Clarity sells not only round brilliant lab diamonds but also other shapes, collectively known as fancy shapes. These include classic shapes such as emerald and princess and more elaborate heart-shaped lab diamonds.

However, the selection of some of the rarer shapes is limited. For example, heart- and pear-shaped lab diamonds are only available in specific sizes and quality ranges. That said, the selection is still very impressive.

What we miss at With Clarity is fancy-colored lab diamonds. Fancy colors are any diamond that is not colorless (not to be confused with white). With Clarity only sells colorless lab diamonds, which are by far the most popular. But colored diamonds are gorgeous. While they are scarce in nature and thus prohibitively expensive, colored lab diamonds can be created at a much lower cost. That makes them affordable to people other than super-rich folks. We hope that With Clarity will eventually add colored diamonds to its inventory.

All told, With Clarity offers an outstanding selection of stones, and you will likely find something suitable. As you’ll learn later, the buying experience and the options for customizing lab diamond jewelry combined with their vast selection of loose lab-created diamonds make them one of the best places to create your own lab-grown diamond jewelry, including engagement rings.

Next, our With Clarity review will examine their preset lab diamonds jewelry and settings inventory.

Diamond Jewelry Selection at With Clarity

Most customization options are limited to rings and more classic jewelry pieces, such as lab diamond stud earrings, pendants, and engagement rings. Diamond jewelry with smaller diamonds will also not be customizable, and diamonds are often not externally graded either.

Sometimes, you may also prefer a preset diamond jewelry piece, so you don’t have to worry about finding a suitable diamond. While we advise against it, in some cases, it makes sense. That’s why we’ll consider the inventory of preset jewelry in this part of our With Clarity review.

Beyond Engagement Rings

A few years ago, With Clarity mainly focused on diamond engagement rings, and their selection of other diamond jewelry was limited. However, that has since changed. Now With Clarity offers everything from classic jewelry designs to more modern, edgy, exquisite, one-of-a-kind pieces.

Below are a few examples, from halo diamond earrings to modern pieces you might find design-first jewelers like Vrai, Kimaï, or Pandora Brilliance.

With Clarity has a large and wide selection of lab diamond jewelry.

In total, With Clarity offers close to 150 lab diamond jewelry pieces, not counting 400+ ring options. While this is fewer than at other jewelers, it’s a decent amount and enough to browse their catalog if you are in the market for lab diamond jewelry.

Somewhat confusingly, a few non-diamond pieces have passed the “lab diamond” filter, as seen below. So look closely and don’t mistake blue topaz for a blue lab diamond or amethyst for purple lab diamonds.

At With Clarity, you can filter for diamond and gemstone type, style and metal.
But, the filters at With Clarity are not perfect and a few non-diamond pieces are included.

The prices for the preset lab diamond jewelry are very fair, and next in our With Clarity review, we’ll examine their prices for both jewelry and diamonds.

With Clarity Prices and Value for Money

Of course, prices are one of the most important aspects when considering a diamond jeweler. To help you determine if With Clarity is good value for money, we’ll compare prices with other leading lab diamond jewelers for both loose and lab diamond jewelry.

First, we’ll use our reference diamond again and compare the price ranges with other jewelers’ inventory of lab diamonds with the same ranges. While this is not a perfect comparison because all diamonds are unique, it does indicate the overall price level.

Prices for Loose Lab-Created Diamonds

At With Clarity, the prices for our reference diamond range from $639 to $2,239. However, lab diamonds range between $800 and $1,100. This puts With Clarity among the cheapest diamond jewelers, including our recommended best places.

Our 1-carat comparison with six other leading lab diamond jewelers found With Clarity slightly more expensive. Still, prices have since dropped, and With Clarity is as affordable as Clean Origin and almost as cheap as Ritani.

If you want to compare other diamond carats or shapes, you can see prices (including those of With Clarity) in our lab diamond price comparisons (2-carat prices, 3-carat prices, lab diamond engagement ring prices, and more lab diamond prices).

As you can see from our other price comparisons, With Clarity is consistently among the cheapest. That is also our overall experience with the company and prices of loose lab-grown diamonds.

But what about lab diamond jewelry prices? Let’s examine that next in our With Clarity review.

Prices for Diamond Jewelry

Comparing prices for lab-grown diamond jewelry is at least as hard as with loose diamonds since jewelry designs are unique. But, there are a few standard designs that almost all jewelers carry, including lab diamond stud earrings.

At With Clarity, a pair of lab-grown diamond stud earrings set with two 0.5-carat diamonds (1-carat total weight) with color H+ and clarity VS2+ costs $900. This makes With Clarity the cheapest on our list below. However, note that the cut quality is only “very good”, which is not, in fact, very good. That makes Ritani the cheapest, but if you customize the earrings at With Clarity and pick an excellent or ideal cut diamond, With Clarity comes out almost as cheap as Ritani.

JewelerClarityColorCutPrice
With ClarityVS2+H+Very Good$900
RitaniVS2+H+Ideal$1,360
Clean OriginVS2+F+Very Good$1,350
Grown BrillianceVS2+F+Excellent$1,750
Vrai*VS2+J+Excellent$1,900
KimaïVS2+F+Very Good$2,695
A diamond price comparison of With Clarity vs. the competition.

We have also compared prices for other types of jewelry, and, again, With Clarity is one of the cheapest places to buy lab-created diamond jewelry.

In summary, With Clarity is among the best-priced jewelers for lab-grown loose diamonds and lab diamond jewelry. With excellent prices and a large selection of great lab diamonds, you might consider With Clarity. But how is the buying process? We’ll find out next in our With Clarity review.

The With Clarity Buying Experience

Buying lab-grown diamond jewelry has become much easier with the advent of online jewelers and leading jewelers such as James Allen showing the way. Today, many jewelers offer many of the same features as James Allen, including With Clarity.

One of the unique aspects of With Clarity is their try-before-you-buy home preview. We’ll go into more detail below, but it’s a fantastic service that differentiates With Clarity. Of course, this is specifically for engagement rings, so let’s first review the With Clarity engagement ring buying process.

Engagement Ring Buying Experience

Shopping for engagement rings at With Clarity is exceptional. Only With Clarity offers a unique try-at-home experience (even two versions), letting you assess high-quality replicas of the engagement ring(s) you’re considering. But it doesn’t stop there.

In addition, their engagement ring customization is outstanding. They boast 8,000 customization options, and while we haven’t counted, it’s sufficient to say that you can make your engagement ring entirely your own. If this is important to you, go With Clarity.

How to create your own ring at With Clarity.

Diamond Jewelry Buying Experience

Previously, the customization options at With Clarity were limited to engagement rings, but that has since changed. You can now also customize earrings and necklaces and choose the exact setting and diamond you want to pair. The process is as easy as when creating an engagement ring, and you have just as many lab diamonds to choose between. The number of settings is fewer, but there are enough that you should be able to find what you are looking for.

The process is straightforward, and there are only four steps involved. Here’s a walkthrough of how to build a custom lab diamond pendant.

Assessing the Jewelry Buying Process

First, choose a setting:

How to customize and buy a lab-grown diamond pendant at With Clarity. Step 1: Pick the setting.

When you pick a setting, you’ll land on a more detailed page where you can learn more about the particular design, and you can choose length, metal, etc.:

How to customize and buy a lab-grown diamond pendant at With Clarity. Step 2: Select style.

Once you have decided on the setting, you are presented with a preset filter of the diamonds that fit that setting:

How to customize and buy a lab-grown diamond pendant at With Clarity. Step 3: Compare diamonds.

As we showed earlier in this With Clarity review, you can filter diamonds based on all diamond 4Cs and additional features. Compare the diamonds that fit with your desired diamond attributes and pick the one that is the best value. If you need help or tips, read our guide to buying loose diamonds or how to buy a lab-grown diamond.

Once you’ve decided on a diamond, all you need to do is add it to the pendant, and you’re all set:

How to customize and buy a lab-grown diamond pendant at With Clarity. Step 4: Add the diamond to the pendant.

Consider preset lab diamond jewelry if you are after a more elaborate or unique design. However, we recommend that you contact their customer service to inquire about pairing with diamonds of higher cut quality than very good.

Diamond Inspection Features

Diamond inspection at With Clarity is also good, and you can view almost any diamond in 360 degrees and study it. However, the quality of the images/video is not as good as at some competitors, and we miss the ability to zoom in and inspect the diamond in more detail.

With Clarity Review: 360 degree inspection
See how the 360-degree diamond inspection works at With Clarity.

Pros and Cons of Buying Diamonds at With Clarity.

Pros
  • Great overview and search functionality where you can set all your desired parameters and quickly gather an overview of their selection.
  • With Clarity works with all major diamond institutes, and all diamonds have reputable certificates. Typically, that means GIA for mined diamonds and IGI for lab-grown diamonds, and, as we have seen, With Clarity offers a large selection of GIA-graded lab diamonds, too.
  • The certificates are available on the site, as they should be, allowing you to inspect the diamond stones in detail, including any flaws they may have (which is ok, as long as they are not too dominant – learn more in our guide to lab diamond clarity).
  • You can inspect almost any diamond using a 360-degree view, which gives a fairly decent representation of the stone. However, the tools are not nearly as good as those offered by James Allen. We particularly miss the super zoom that James Allen provides.
  • With Clarity has gemologists available for you to interact with and set up virtual appointments, and the customer support is excellent and very helpful.
  • A lifetime warranty, free delivery, and free and insured returns—plus free resizing—are all to be expected by a top-tier jeweler, but sadly, this is not always the case. Fortunately, With Clarity does.
Cons
  • While most diamonds can be inspected using the 360-degree tool, a few are missing. These, however, are only smaller diamonds, and you can avoid those few diamonds. The inspection tool is decent but not as advanced as some competitors offer. However, we miss the super zoom that James Allen has.
  • There are a few issues on the website, such as non-diamond gemstones passing through the filter. We also often experience slow loading times, but these are usually momentary, and, as you will have learned by now, it’s well worth the occasional wait.
  • We would like to see an option to pick preset jewelry with a better diamond cut grade. But you can either customize online and choose your own diamond(s) or try contacting their customer service for a better diamond.

Summary of the With Clarity Customer Experience

Despite minor flaws and missing features, the shopping experience at With Clarity is fantastic. If you are looking for a lab-created diamond engagement ring, With Clarity is one of the absolute best places to shop. The Home Preview offering alone makes With Clarity stand out, but the endless customization options and customer support seal the deal.

On that note, let’s quickly zoom in on the try-before-you-buy service. Read our in-depth review of With Clarity’s Home Preview to learn more.

Engagement Ring Preview at Home

The With Clarity Home Preview is a unique offering that allows you to try up to two engagement ring replicas at home before deciding. While other jewelers offer something similar, With Clarity’s home preview is much better than anything else we’ve experienced.

Oh, did we mention that it’s completely free? If you return the replica rings in time, you don’t even pay for shipping! That is excellent value for (no) money! So, if you are shopping for engagement rings, we suggest you start your search at With Clarity.

You may be wondering just how this works. Well, it’s pretty simple.

  1. You create a “home preview box” and select two rings. Next, you customize the carat, shape, and type of metal.
  2. You receive 3D models of the two rings you chose for you to try at home. You have to return them within three days.
  3. After returning the replicas, you can order the one you liked best (or make any custom changes).
With Clarity Review - Home Preview of Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Rings

This might leave you with a couple of questions about the Home Preview. Let’s answer them!

With Clarity Home Preview Quick Facts

What is the quality of the With Clarity engagement ring home preview replica like? Is it anything like the real deal?

Yes, the quality is surprisingly good and definitely good enough for you to make an informed decision. Now, it’s only the design that you are evaluating, not the diamond stone. The one placed in the ring setting is a synthetic replica stone (remember how lab-grown diamonds are not synthetic but, in fact, just as real as mined diamonds).

How long do I have to return the engagement ring replica?

You can only keep the diamond ring replica from With Clarity for three days. After that, you’ll have to return it. Fortunately, that is also free. But if you need to keep it for longer, just contact their customer service and ask for an extension.

What does the With Clarity engagement ring home preview cost?

It’s completely free of charge. This is the main reason we recommend the With Clarity Home Preview and With Clarity—despite your not being able to assess in diamond stone. This is a perfect way to decide on the design, particularly if it is essential to you and if you find it challenging to decide.

The Try-Before-You-Buy ring box.

Learn more in our in-depth review of the With Clarity Home Preview.

With Clarity Shipping and Return Policies

With Clarity’s shipping is always free. As it should be, but it’s often not the case (read, for example, our reviews of Zales or Helzberg). All orders are shipped with 2-day insured shipping with FedEx. While Clean Origin and James Allen offer free overnight shipping, the 2-day insured and free shipping is more than adequate and better than most jewelers offer.

The return policies are generous, too. You have 30 days of hassle-free returns with both postage and insurance paid, which is pretty much less risk-free. It may not be as generous as Clean Origin’s 100-day return period, but it’s on par with our other recommended lab diamond jewelers.

With Clarity Review Summary and Verdict

Our With Clarity review concludes that With Clarity is a leading seller of lab-grown diamond engagement rings. The option to try replicas at home before you buy (to assess the design), the excellent value, and maybe most importantly, the endless abilities to customize your engagement ring catapults With Clarity to another league.

Our updated 2024 With Clarity review finds that they excel not only in engagement rings but are also among the very best when it comes to loose lab-grown diamonds and lab diamond jewelry.

The selection of lab-created diamonds at With Clarity is vast, and their prices are among the best we’ve found anywhere. We miss colored lab diamonds, and some fancy shapes are in limited supply, but for anything else, With Clarity is one of the best options.

That also goes for their preset jewelry, such as lab diamond stud earrings.

The prices and selection are similar to those of Clean Origin, and prices are nearly as low as at Ritani. If diamond inspection and advanced features are important to you, James Allen offers a better buying experience (than anyone), but for most, what you’ll find at With Clarity is more than sufficient, and we have no hesitation in recommending With Clarity.

We land at 4.6 stars out of 5, leaving With Clarity among the few top-rated diamond sellers at LabGrownCarats.com.

The ring box from our secret shopping at With Clarity.

How We Reviewed With Clarity

As experts in lab-created diamonds, we have conducted a thorough analysis of With Clarity, including their diamonds and jewelry. Our team has compared With Clarity with its competitors and evaluated the pros and cons against industry standards. We have spent countless days and weeks reviewing With Clarity, utilizing our experience and expertise. 

To ensure accuracy, our team investigated the shopping experience, purchased and returned products, studied the actual diamonds and jewelry, and tested the craftsmanship. We also subjected With Clarity’s customer service to a barrage of questions that you, as a customer, might have. 

Our diamond jeweler reviews, including With Clarity, are updated several times yearly to stay current. We encourage you to share your own experiences with us in the comments section so we can include them in our assessments. 

Why You Should Trust Us

Our team of diamond experts has accumulated decades of knowledge of diamonds and jewelers, with a combined experience of more than 75 years. Rolf Hartmann, our top diamond expert, led the With Clarity review with input from several expert contributors.

Ranking Criteria

We have evaluated and ranked With Clarity using these criteria:

  • Price
  • Diamond inventory
  • Jewelry selection
  • Quality
  • Shopping experience
  • Customer service
  • Sustainability
  • Shipping and return policies

Our Readers’ With Clarity Reviews

We encourage our readers to share their experiences shopping at With Clarity. Read our visitors’ With Clarity customer reviews below.

0.0
0.0 out of 5 stars (based on 0 reviews)
Excellent0%
Very good0%
Average0%
Poor0%
Terrible0%

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Other Customer Feedback and Reviews

Unsurprisingly, With Clarity’s customers agree with the conclusions of our With Clarity review, and we do not hesitate to thoroughly recommend With Clarity for any lab-grown diamond needs – especially lab-created diamond engagement rings.

This is evident from all the positives and only a few drawbacks. If you’re looking for an engagement ring, look no further. If you are looking for any other lab-grown diamond jewelry, try With Clarity, but compare it to Clean Origin, Ritani, Brilliant Earth, and James Allen.

With Clarity Review - Google Ratings

Tips for Buying a Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Ring Online

Learn more about buying a lab-grown diamond engagement ring online in our guides below:

3 diamond jewelers we also like
Share with your friends...
Rolf Hartmann
Rolf Hartmann

Rolf Hartmann has decades of experience in the jewelry industry. He knows everything you need to know to find the perfect diamond. He's an expert in lab-grown diamonds and has followed the exciting development of lab diamonds from industrial usage to the incredible gemstone quality that lab-grown diamonds are today. Rolf guides you to find the right diamond at the best possible price and expertly and transparently reviews all lab-grown diamond sellers.

Articles: 98

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *