We test all recommended products and services independently and exhaustively. If you buy through our links, we might receive compensation. Our recommendations are not influenced by monetary considerations. Learn more.
Is your anniversary approaching, and are you still wondering what you should get your significant other as an anniversary present? Don’t worry! At LabGrownCarats, we’ve tested hundreds of lab-grown diamond jewelers and curated this 2025 guide to help you find the perfect anniversary diamond gift. We’re here to help you find the perfect diamond anniversary present — and save money!
Why Diamonds Make the Perfect Anniversary Gift
Each wedding anniversary is traditionally associated with a gemstone for that year. For instance, the first wedding anniversary recommendation is gold, the second anniversary is garnet, the third anniversary is pearls, the fourth anniversary is blue topaz, the fifth anniversary is sapphire, and so on.
While there are gemstones for each anniversary year, that doesn’t mean that you can (or should) only buy that particular gemstone as an anniversary present. On the contrary! Every relationship is unique, and people celebrate milestones in their own way.
A wedding anniversary is a perfect time to give your loved one a unique gift, and nothing is more precious than diamond jewelry. A sparkling diamond is a beautiful and memorable way of honoring your marriage, memories, and your love for each other.
SALES ALERT! See the best diamond deals (terms apply):
Lab Diamonds: The More Ethical and Sustainable Diamond Choice
Before we dive into the lab-grown diamond anniversary present, let’s go through some of the most common questions about lab-grown diamonds.
Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds. They are 100% identical in composition, brilliance, and beauty to their mined counterparts, but they are a more sustainable and ethical choice.
Traditional diamond mining can cause severe ecological damage and often lacks transparency in its supply chain. In contrast, lab-grown diamonds are traceable, conflict-free, and environmentally conscious—so you can celebrate your love responsibly.
Read more about why diamonds are an ethical and environmentally friendly choice.
What is a Good Diamond Jewelry Gift For an Anniversary?
One of the common worries is getting your partner a gift that they won’t like. And that’s also the case with diamond anniversary presents. A good piece of advice is to think about the person you’re gifting. What diamond jewelry piece you should get your significant other depends on the preference and style of the person you’re buying a lab-grown diamond jewelry gift for.
Still not sure what diamond anniversary present to get? Generally, diamond rings are one of the most common choices for anniversary gifts. For example, diamond anniversary rings or eternity rings are a highly popular way to mark a significant milestone.
The eternity ring symbolizes eternal love, and what better way to celebrate an anniversary? The great thing about an eternity ring or anniversary ring is that it can be stacked alongside your engagement or wedding ring while also worn on its own.
That said, you’re not limited to celebrating an anniversary with a diamond ring. Diamond earrings, necklaces, and bracelets also make excellent anniversary gifts.
And even with a smaller budget, you’ll be able to find an exceptionally beautiful piece of diamond jewelry gift, thanks to the lower cost of lab-grown diamonds. If you need inspiration, read our guide to the best lab-grown gifts under $1000.
If, unexpectedly, the diamond anniversary present is not quite right, then don’t worry. All the best online diamond retailers offer outstanding return policies.
The Best Lab Diamond Anniversary Presents in 2025
To help you get started, we have put together a list of lab-grown diamond jewelry that is perfect as anniversary gifts, no matter the milestone you’re celebrating.
These lab-grown diamond anniversary presents will suit anyone’s style and personality, and you’ll be sure to surprise and make your significant other incredibly happy.
Brilliant Earth Riviera Eternity Lab Diamond Ring 1 ct.
This gorgeous eternity ring from Brilliant Earth is the first on our list of diamond anniversary presents. It’s a modern and chic take on the classic eternity ring, which symbolizes eternal love. The floating diamond setting secures the diamonds while creating a light and delicate appearance. It’s available in 1 ct. and 2 ct. (total weight) and in a range of metal types.
Why we love it: Timeless design and meticulous craftsmanship.
Number of diamonds: 18-22 and 22-26 | Total carat weight range: 0.97-1.14 and 2.02-2.46 | Setting: Shared prong | Average color: F/G | Average clarity: SI
James Allen French Pave Lab-Created Diamond Eternity Ring
Next on our list of the best lab diamond anniversary presents is this stunning French Pave Diamond Eternity Ring, a delicate and gorgeous option from top-rated diamond retailer James Allen. It can be ordered in various metal types and is available in different carat sizes, ranging from 0.75 CTW to 3 CTW. Note that the number of diamonds and the carat total weight will vary depending on ring size and style.
Why we love it: Dazzling yet delicate, this ring offers effortless sophistication and customizable sparkle for any milestone.
Available in metal: 14kt white gold, 14kt yellow gold, 14kt rose gold, and platinum | Average color: F-G | Average clarity: VS
Ritani Round-Cut Lab Diamond Eternity Ring
This classic eternity band from Ritani features round brilliant-cut lab-grown diamonds and is another excellent diamond anniversary present. The sparkling design is sure to catch your attention. Diamonds in prong settings are held close together for a secure look. This stunning eternity band is available in 2 ct. and all the way up to 6 ct. Please note that the number of diamonds and the total carat weight will vary depending on the ring size.
Why we love it: A classic eternity band with exceptional brilliance and unbeatable value.
Available in metal: 14kt white gold, 18kt white gold, 18kt yellow gold, and platinum | Carat total weight: will vary based on ring size.
James Allen Four Prong Basket Solitaire Diamond Pendant
This stunning round brilliant diamond from James Allen is set in a four-prong wire basket designed to showcase the round brilliant diamond’s unique beauty and sparkle. The solitaire pendant comes in .25, 0-50, 0.75, and 1ctw. and is attached to an 18-cable link chain. It’s a classic, slightly understated, but stunning diamond anniversary present that anyone would cherish.
Pro tip: You can also customize your diamond pendant and select a diamond of your choice. We always recommend this since you’ll be able to decide the diamond cut, carat, clarity, and color that best fit your criteria and budget while viewing lab grading reports. This way, you’ll end up with the best possible diamond.
Why we love it: Elegant simplicity that goes with everything.
Average color: F-G | Average clarity: VS | Available in metal: 14kt white gold, 14kt yellow gold, and platinum
Brilliant Earth Arabella Diamond Pendant
This Brilliant Earth Arabella Diamond Pendant is absolutely gorgeous and a very romantic take on a diamond pendant anniversary present. We particularly love that you can create your own necklace by choosing the lab-grown diamond of your choice. First, you select the setting (this diamond pendant comes in various metal types). Next, you can select the diamond (videos, pictures, and grading report are available while you browse), and voilà, you will have this beautiful, sparkling diamond pendant.
Why we love it: Romantic and customizable, this pendant lets you design a personal piece that feels both modern and meaningful.
Shape: round or oval | Metal types: 14kt rose gold, 18kt white gold, 18kt yellow gold, and platinum
Brilliant Earth Halo Earrings
Another option for a sparkling diamond anniversary present is these beautiful Halo Earrings from Brilliant Earth. The central stone is surrounded by a halo of pavé-set diamond accents, which beautifully enhance the center stone. You get to choose the diamond yourself, which we love.
Why we love it: A radiant halo enhances every sparkle. It’s ideal for those who love statement brilliance with refined craftsmanship.
Shape: round | Setting: three-prong | Average color of accent stones: F/G | Average clarity of accent stones: SI1 | Backing: push backs
Brilliant Earth Lotus Flower Lab Diamond Earrings
Next on our list of diamond anniversary presents, we have these absolutely stunning Brilliant Earth earrings featuring 10 halo blooms around a sparkling center diamond. You customize these earrings by selecting the diamonds of your choice, which is much better than buying a ready-to-ship pair of diamond earrings because you get to examine all the diamond details and check the grading report before deciding on the ideal diamonds. You generally get a much better deal and diamond this way. And don’t worry. It’s straightforward to customize and select your diamonds of choice at Brilliant Earth’s easy-to-navigate website.
Why we love it: A floral design that represents growth and lasting love.
Shape: round | Min. carat total weight of accent stones: 0.54 (pick your own center stone) | Setting: prong set | Average color of accent stones: F/G | Average clarity of accent stones: SI1 | Backing: guardian backs or push backs
Anniversary Gifts FAQ
Diamond rings are one of the most common gemstone gifts. Especially a diamond eternity band is a highly popular way to mark an anniversary. Other popular gemstone anniversary gifts include diamond earrings, necklaces, and bracelets.
The traditional gift for a tenth anniversary is diamond jewelry, especially diamond rings like eternity rings, which symbolize eternal love.
Each anniversary year has traditional and modern gift themes. For example, the 1st year is paper, the 5th is wood, the 10th is tin, and the 25th is silver. Diamonds are commonly associated with milestone anniversaries, such as the 10th or 60th.
Best Places to Buy Diamond Presents
3 Diamond Jewelers We Like
See more ideas in our guide to lab-created diamond anniversary rings.
